Role Play & Communication·Lesson 4.2·7 min read
Breaking Bad News
What are bad news stations?
As a dentist, you'll sometimes have to give patients bad news, such as a tooth that can't be saved, and how you do it matters, because patients often remember that conversation for years. Dental schools want to see how you'd handle this, which is why breaking bad news is one of the most common role plays at interview. The news is usually something everyday rather than a diagnosis, such as telling a neighbour that you've lost their dog. The actor will usually react with shock, anger or tears, so you need to give the news clearly, stay calm while they react, and help them work out what to do next.
Examples of bad news stations
The news can be about anything from a lost pet to a cancelled appointment. For example:
- "You were looking after your neighbour's dog while they were on holiday, and he has gone missing. They're back, and at your door."
- "You work at a dry cleaner's and have accidentally ruined a customer's dress. She's just come in to collect it."
- "You're a dental nurse. The dentist has gone home ill, and a patient who has taken the morning off work for a filling will have to rebook."
The SPIKES framework
For these stations, we recommend SPIKES, the standard framework for breaking bad news to patients:
- 1.Setting. Where you deliver news can affect how it's received. In a busy corridor with people walking past, the other person may not be able to react properly, and it can seem like you don't care. So suggest somewhere quiet. Even in a role play, saying "Shall we sit down somewhere quieter?" shows you've thought about the setting.
- 2.Perception. Try to find out how much they know before you say anything. Somebody who already suspects something is wrong needs a different conversation from somebody who has no idea. Some actors may have the wrong idea completely, so ask first to make sure you're both starting from the same place.
- 3.Invitation. Bad news leaves people with very little control. Asking "Would it be okay if I explained what's happened?" gives a little of it back, and lets them hear the news when they're ready.
- 4.Knowledge. Bad news is harder to take in when the person isn't expecting it. So start with a warning shot, like "I'm afraid I have some difficult news", which gives them a moment to prepare themselves. Then give the facts plainly and slowly.
- 5.Emotions. People need time to take in bad news, but most candidates rush this step. After the news, stop talking and let there be some silence, so that the next words come from them. Then acknowledge how they feel before you try to fix anything.
- 6.Strategy. Once they're ready, agree a plan together that covers what happens next and what support there is. People in shock often don't take much in, so check they've understood before you finish.
A worked example
"You were looking after your neighbour Sam's dog, Milo, while they were on holiday. Milo has gone missing, and Sam is back, at your door. Break the news."
Here is a strong answer, following the six steps of SPIKES:
- 1.Setting. "Hi Sam, welcome back. Have you got a few minutes? Come in and sit down."
- 2.Perception. "Did you see any of my messages while you were away?" Sam says no, so you know the news will come as a complete shock.
- 3.Invitation. "There's something I need to tell you about Milo. Is it okay if I explain what's happened?"
- 4.Knowledge. "I'm afraid it's difficult news, and I'm really sorry. On Tuesday evening Milo got out while I was feeding him, and I haven't been able to find him. That's my responsibility."
- 5.Emotions. You stop talking. Sam gets angry: "How could you let this happen? I trusted you!" You don't defend yourself or explain again. "You have every right to be angry. You trusted me with him, and I let you down. I'm so sorry." Then you wait, and let Sam say everything they need to.
- 6.Strategy. When Sam is calmer: "Would it help if I told you what I've done so far? I've spoken to the neighbours, called the local vets and the rescue centre, and posted on the local Facebook group. I'd like to keep searching with you this evening. Is there anywhere he likes to go that I should try first? I'll do everything I can to help find him."
This answer does three things well. The news comes with a warning and in plain words, with no excuses and no attempt to make it sound less serious ("it's just a dog"). When Sam gets angry, you stay calm. The actor in this station is briefed to get angry and then settle, so Sam will get angry however well you deliver the news, and you're being tested on whether you get defensive. The plan is also honest and shared, because you ask Sam where to look, and you say "I'll do everything I can", not "I promise we'll find him", which you can't guarantee.
Bad news about a patient's health
In some stations you play the dentist, and the news is about the patient's health. Any facts you need are in the brief, and you follow the same six steps. For example:
"You are a dentist in a hospital clinic. Colin, aged 61, had a small sample taken from an ulcer on his tongue that hadn't healed. The result shows mouth cancer. The area is small, and he will be seen urgently by a specialist team, who will arrange scans. Break the news to him."
Dentists check the lining of the mouth at every examination, so they are often the first to notice an ulcer like Colin's. Here is how three of the steps sound in this station:
- Perception. "Before I go through the result, can you tell me what you understand about why the sample was taken?" Colin thinks a broken tooth caused the ulcer and expects good news, so you know the result will be a shock.
- Knowledge. "I'm afraid the result is more serious than we had hoped. I'm very sorry to tell you that the sample shows the ulcer is a type of mouth cancer." Say the word "cancer", because words like "growth" leave patients unsure what they've been told. Then stop talking.
- Emotions. Colin may ask "Am I going to die?" Don't answer "You'll be fine", because you can't promise it. Say what you do know: "I can't give you a clear answer yet, because we need scans to understand more. What I can tell you is that the area is small, and you're going to be seen quickly by a specialist team."
For the plan, give him the next steps from the brief in small pieces, and tell him who he can phone with questions.
Tips for breaking bad news well
SPIKES gives you the order of the conversation. These tips help with the parts candidates most often get wrong:
Give all the bad news at once. The news often has two parts: what went wrong, and what it means for them. A cancelled filling also means another morning off work and more days with a sore tooth. If you hold the second part back, they'll get upset twice.
Explain why it matters. In a clinical station, say briefly why the treatment is still needed before you talk about rebooking. Otherwise the patient may decide not to come back.
Ask what would help. People who are upset often reject the fixes you suggest, but it's hard to reject one they asked for. Apologise once or twice, then follow it with a question: "I'm really sorry. What would help most right now?" Repeating "sorry" without doing anything tends to make people angrier.
Only offer what you can do. Don't make up options the brief doesn't give you, like an appointment with another dentist that afternoon. If something is outside your role, offer to fetch someone who can help.
What's next
The next lesson covers other difficult conversations, where you have to calm someone who is angry, say no, or confront a friend or colleague.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle role play questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.