Ethical Questions·Lesson 3.1·7 min read
Introduction to Ethics Stations
What an ethics station is
In an ethics station, you will be presented with a scenario where the right course of action may not be immediately obvious, often because different ethical principles or responsibilities conflict. For example, a patient might ask for healthy teeth to be removed, a parent might refuse the extractions their child needs, or two patients might need the one emergency appointment left that day. You will be asked to explain how you would approach the situation, with the interviewer assessing your ability to weigh up competing considerations, justify your decisions and reach a well-reasoned conclusion.
Why schools ask them
Dentists make ethical decisions every day: whether a patient can consent, what a patient needs to know about the cost of their options, who gets seen first. Dental schools select for the values these decisions depend on, such as honesty, respect for patients and putting their interests first. You aren't expected to know the law in detail, but you are expected to reason fairly and safely and to know the basic rules dentists work within.
The four types of ethics question
Ethics questions come in four main types. When you get a question, first work out which type it is, because each is answered differently.
- 1.Dilemmas. You are given a scenario where two ethical principles conflict. "Should dental implants be offered on the NHS?" "Is it fair for private patients to get longer appointments than NHS patients?" There's no single right answer, and reasonable dentists disagree. You will be assessed on how effectively you evaluate different arguments and reach a well-reasoned conclusion. For most questions, the position you take is less important than the quality of your reasoning and how convincingly you justify your view. The exception is where a particular position would involve breaking the law, in which case you must always support the lawful course of action.
- 2.Professionalism. In these scenarios, you will be presented with a situation where someone's behaviour falls short of the professional standards expected of them. "The dentist you're shadowing doesn't change gloves between patients." "A friend is copying answers in an exam." These sound like dilemmas but usually aren't. Patient safety comes first, and doing nothing is never right. What's being tested is whether your response matches the risk: a quiet word for something minor, escalating appropriately when patients could be harmed.
- 3.Your own mistake. These ask what you'd do when something has gone wrong because of an error you made. "You've given a patient another patient's aftercare sheet." This also has a right answer: make the patient safe, be honest with them and your seniors, and learn from it. What's being tested is honesty under pressure, because covering up a mistake is treated far more seriously than the mistake itself.
- 4.Knowledge. These ask you to explain a legal or ethical concept rather than respond to a situation. "What is Gillick competence?" "When can a dentist break confidentiality?" These check that you know the key law and guidance and can explain it clearly, with an example. They often turn into a scenario: "...and what would you do here?"
Many stations combine types. A parent refusing treatment for their child is a dilemma, but you can't answer it well without knowing the law on consent for children. Some questions are about your own professional boundaries, such as a patient offering you a gift or asking for your number. These follow the same thinking, so they're covered in the professionalism lesson.
Each type has its own approach, covered in the following lessons. The four pillars of medical ethics and the GDC's nine principles are useful for all four types.
The four pillars of medical ethics
Most ethical questions in dentistry come back to four principles, known as the four pillars of medical ethics. Much of the law and the GDC's guidance reflects them, and they often pull against each other, which is what makes a situation a dilemma. When you answer, as a minimum explain how each of the four pillars applies to the scenario, in a sentence each rather than as a list. Stronger answers also identify where the pillars conflict. For example, if an adult with capacity refuses to have an infected tooth taken out, respecting their autonomy may conflict with beneficence, as you want to honour their decision while also acting in their best interests.
The four pillars are:
Autonomy: a patient's right to make their own decisions. An adult with capacity can refuse treatment, even treatment their dentist strongly recommends, and even if the decision seems unwise. But autonomy doesn't mean patients get whatever they want. They can refuse a treatment, but they can't insist on one the dentist doesn't think is clinically appropriate, such as having healthy teeth removed.
Beneficence: acting in the patient's best interests. This is about actively doing good, such as providing effective treatment to relieve their pain and keep their mouth healthy. It used to be read as "the professional knows best", which today is called paternalism. Now the patient's own values help decide what their best interests are, so the right treatment for one patient can be the wrong one for another. This is why beneficence can't be separated from autonomy.
Non-maleficence: avoiding harm. This is the principle behind "first, do no harm". Almost every treatment carries some risk, even an injection of local anaesthetic, so in practice it's about proportion: the benefit has to justify the risk. It carries extra weight when a patient asks for cosmetic treatment, because their teeth are healthy to begin with and any harm is harder to justify.
Justice: treating patients fairly and distributing healthcare resources equitably. This means ensuring that patients receive fair treatment regardless of their background, lifestyle or behaviour, while recognising that different patients have different needs. Justice also involves allocating limited resources fairly, such as giving the last emergency appointment of the day to the patient with the greater clinical need rather than to whoever arrived first.
The GDC and its nine principles
The General Dental Council (GDC) regulates the whole dental team in the UK, including dentists, dental nurses, hygienists and therapists. Its core guidance, Standards for the Dental Team, sets out nine principles that every registered dental professional must follow, and falling seriously short of them can lead to fitness to practise proceedings. In plain words, a dental professional must:
- 1.Put patients' interests first. This includes putting them before the dentist's own income or the income of the practice.
- 2.Communicate effectively with patients. Explain things in a way the patient understands, and listen to them.
- 3.Obtain valid consent. The patient agrees to treatment only after hearing their options, the risks and the costs.
- 4.Maintain and protect patients' information. Keep what patients tell you, and their records, confidential.
- 5.Have a clear and effective complaints procedure. Patients know how to complain and get a proper response when they do.
- 6.Work with colleagues in a way that is in patients' best interests. Dentistry is delivered by a team, and the team works for the patient.
- 7.Maintain, develop and work within their professional knowledge and skills. Keep up to date, and refer the patient to someone else when a treatment is beyond their training.
- 8.Raise concerns if patients are at risk. Speak up about anything that could harm a patient, including a colleague's behaviour.
- 9.Make sure their personal behaviour maintains patients' confidence in them and in the dental profession. This applies outside work and online as well as in the surgery.
Dental students aren't registered with the GDC, so a dental school deals with any concern about its own students' fitness to practise. Students are still expected to work towards the same standards, and the GDC's guidance for students, Student Professionalism and Fitness to Practise, explains how the standards apply to them.
Using the principles in an answer
You don't need to recite all nine in an answer. Refer to the one or two that apply to the scenario, because an accurate reference makes your answer stronger. "I don't think a dentist should recommend the treatment that earns the most" is an opinion. "The GDC requires dentists to put patients' interests before their own financial gain" is a professional standard. If you're not sure what the standards say on a point, say what you'd expect them to say rather than inventing a quote.
You may also be asked about the principles directly, and a common version is "Which of the nine GDC principles do you think is the most important?" Any of the nine can be a good choice, because the interviewer is listening to your reasons. Say first that a dentist has to meet all nine, then choose one, explain how it supports several of the others, and give a short example from your work experience:
"All nine matter, and a dentist has to meet every one of them. If I had to choose, I'd say putting patients' interests first, because the others follow from it. A dentist who puts the patient first will explain the options clearly, respect the patient's decision and keep their information private. On work experience, I watched a dentist see a patient who wanted a painful tooth taken out straight away. She explained that the tooth could be saved, went through the benefits, risks and costs of both options, and gave him time to think. He chose to keep the tooth. Taking it out would have been quicker, but she put his long-term interest first."
The later lessons draw on the GDC's rules on consent, confidentiality, raising concerns and being open with patients when something goes wrong.
What's next
The next lesson covers dilemmas: how to weigh up both sides, use the pillars to find the real tension, and still reach a clear view.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle ethics questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.