Motivation for Dentistry·Lesson 2.2·7 min read
Why Not Medicine, or Another Dental Role?
Dentistry and medicine have a lot in common, and many people who apply for one have thought about the other. Dental schools know this, so they often ask why you chose dentistry and not medicine. A dentist also works every day with dental nurses, hygienists and therapists, so you may be asked why you want to be the dentist and not another member of the team. Both questions test whether you understand what is different about a dentist's role, and whether your reasons apply to dentistry in particular. This lesson covers a four-step method for answering them, with a worked answer for each question.
Examples of these questions
Medicine is the career you're most likely to be asked to compare with dentistry, but the question can be about any related career:
- "Why dentistry and not medicine?"
- "Why do you want to be a dentist rather than a dental nurse, hygienist or therapist?"
- "What is it about dentistry that stands out from other healthcare careers?"
How to answer a comparison question
We recommend four steps, which are the same whichever career you're asked about:
- 1.Show respect for the other career. Keep it to one or two sentences, ideally about something you've seen. If you praise the other career at length, you use up your time and can sound as though you'd be just as happy doing it.
- 2.Give one or two accurate differences. Describe them as differences in the role, not in importance. Your interviewer may be a doctor or a dental therapist, or may work with them every day, so they will notice an inaccurate answer straight away.
- 3.Link the difference to you. Say why it matters to you, using what you found most interesting when you were exploring dentistry. This makes the answer personal to you.
- 4.Say that dentistry is your choice. End your answer by saying so clearly.
Why dentistry and not medicine?
Dentists and doctors both diagnose and treat patients, but their work differs in four ways that you can use in your answer:
- Dentists treat with their own hands. A dentist finds the problem and usually carries out the treatment personally, often in the same visit. In much of medicine, the doctor who makes the diagnosis prescribes medicines or refers the patient to someone else for a procedure.
- One area in depth. Dentistry is focused on the mouth, teeth and jaws. Medicine covers the whole body, and doctors choose a specialty after they qualify.
- Long-term patients in the community. Most dentists work in general practice, where they see the same patients for regular check-ups over many years and spend much of their time on prevention.
- Earlier independence. After a five-year degree and a year of foundation training, a dentist can work in general practice and can go on to own a practice. Doctors train for several more years before they work independently.
Some of these features are shared with parts of medicine, because GPs also know their patients for years and surgeons also work with their hands. Describe them as typical of dentistry, and avoid saying that doctors never do them. Don't give shorter training, better hours or easier entry as your reason either, because none of them says why you want to do a dentist's work.
"Why dentistry and not medicine?"
Here is an answer that follows the four steps:
- 1.Show respect for the other career. "I did think seriously about medicine, and I have a lot of respect for doctors. My aunt is a GP, and I know from her how much she has to know about every part of the body."
- 2.Give one or two accurate differences. "What I noticed when I observed in a dental practice was that the dentist found the problem and then treated it herself, with her own hands, often in the same appointment. Dentistry is also focused on one area, so a dentist knows it in great depth."
- 3.Link the difference to you. "That suits me, because I've always enjoyed careful, practical work. I've made jewellery since Year 9, and I like being able to see at the end whether I've done it well. One patient came in with a broken front tooth the day before a job interview, and she left an hour later smiling. I'd find it very satisfying to be the person who did that for her. I also liked that the dentist knew whole families and talked to them about preventing problems."
- 4.Say that dentistry is your choice. "So medicine is a career I admire, but having looked at both, dentistry is the one that fits what I enjoy and what I'm good at."
The part of this answer about medicine is short, and it shows that the candidate respects medicine and did consider it. The two differences are accurate and don't criticise medicine, and the candidate links them to a hobby and to a patient they saw.
Why a dentist and not another member of the dental team?
To answer this question, you need to know what the other members of the team do:
- Dental nurses support the dentist at the chairside, prepare the surgery and the instruments, look after infection control and reassure patients. They don't diagnose or plan treatment.
- Dental hygienists prevent and treat gum disease and give advice on oral health.
- Dental therapists do the work of a hygienist, and also place fillings in adult and baby teeth and take out baby teeth.
Hygienists and therapists examine patients, take X-rays and give local anaesthetic. Since 2013, patients have been able to see them without being referred by a dentist. It would therefore be inaccurate to say that hygienists and therapists "only clean teeth", or that only a dentist can diagnose.
The dentist diagnoses across the whole of dentistry, and usually takes overall responsibility for the patient's treatment plan and leads the team. The dentist also carries out the full range of treatment, including root canal treatment, crowns and taking out adult teeth, which are outside a therapist's scope. Only dentists can train as specialists, such as orthodontists.
"Why do you want to be a dentist rather than a dental nurse, hygienist or therapist?"
Here is an answer that follows the same four steps:
- 1.Show respect for the other career. "A dental practice couldn't run without the whole team. Where I did my work experience, the dental nurse was the one who calmed a nervous patient down before his extraction. I also watched the therapist place fillings for children, so I know how much treatment therapists and hygienists carry out themselves."
- 2.Give one or two accurate differences. "The difference I saw is that the dentist diagnoses across the whole of dentistry and is responsible for the overall treatment plan. The dentist also does the treatment that's outside the others' scope, such as root canals and crowns."
- 3.Link the difference to you. "That's the part that interests me most. I watched the dentist go through an X-ray with a patient and explain three options for a broken tooth, with what each would cost and how long it would last. I'd like to be the person who works that out and takes responsibility for it."
- 4.Say that dentistry is your choice. "So I respect every role in the team, but the dentist's role is the one I want to train for."
This answer describes the therapist's work accurately. The difference it gives is the dentist's responsibility for the diagnosis and the plan, and it doesn't suggest that the dentist is more important than the rest of the team.
Other careers you might be asked about
You can use the same four steps for any other career. The only part that changes is the difference you describe:
| Career | What it shares with dentistry | A fair difference |
|---|---|---|
| Nurse | Caring for patients as part of a team | Nurses spend more time with each patient. A dentist diagnoses and carries out the treatment |
| Pharmacist | Detailed scientific knowledge, and advising patients | Pharmacists are the experts on medicines. Dentists prescribe some medicines, but most of their treatment is practical |
| Research scientist | Science, and improving treatment for patients | Researchers rarely have an ongoing relationship with patients. A dentist sees the result of their work on one person, and can still do research alongside clinical work |
What's next
The next lesson covers the third motivation question: why this dental school?
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle motivation questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.