Role Play & Communication·Lesson 4.3·7 min read
Difficult Conversations
What are difficult conversation stations?
Doctors regularly have to deal with people who are upset with them, such as a patient who has waited for hours or a relative who wants information they can't have. They also have to speak to colleagues who have done something they shouldn't. Often the doctor didn't cause the problem, but they still have to handle it, and difficult conversation stations test whether you can do the same. The actor will be briefed to argue with you, so you need to stay calm, show that you've understood them, and still be honest about what you can and can't do.
Examples of difficult conversations
There are three main kinds of difficult conversation, with an example of each below:
- Calming an angry person: "A patient has been waiting 45 minutes in a GP surgery and is becoming impatient. You're a medical student on placement. Talk to her."
- Saying no: "You're a medical student sitting with a patient in the waiting room. He asks you to tell him his blood test results."
- Confronting a friend or colleague: "Your friend on placement has posted a photo on social media with a patient visible in the background. Talk to them."
Calming an angry person
For these stations, we recommend four steps: listen, acknowledge, apologise, act.
- 1.Listen. Angry people are usually worried or under pressure, and they can't take in anything you say until they feel heard. So let them finish without interrupting. Stay calm, and lower your voice rather than raising it, because people tend to match the tone of whoever they're talking to.
- 2.Acknowledge. Telling an angry person to calm down rarely works, because it suggests they have no reason to be upset. Say what you can see instead: "I can see you're really frustrated."
- 3.Apologise. Say sorry for what they've been through: "I'm really sorry you've been kept waiting." An apology isn't an admission of fault, so there's no reason to hold it back, and it often calms the conversation down.
- 4.Act. Find out what matters most to them, and why they're angry. Then explain what you can do, and offer realistic options, which might include asking someone more senior to help.
Throughout, don't get defensive, don't blame colleagues, and don't promise anything you can't control.
A worked example
"A patient has been waiting 45 minutes in a GP surgery and is becoming impatient. You're a medical student on placement, going around the waiting room. Talk to the patient, calm her down and offer support."
Here is a strong answer, following the four steps:
- 1.Listen. "Hello, I'm one of the medical students here. I can see you've been waiting a while. Is everything okay?" She tells you, loudly, that she's been here 45 minutes, nobody has told her anything, and this GP is always late. You let her finish.
- 2.Acknowledge. "That sounds really frustrating, especially when nobody has kept you updated."
- 3.Apologise. "I'm sorry you've been kept waiting this long."
- 4.Act. "Can I ask what's worrying you most about the wait?" She says she's meeting friends for lunch and can only wait another 15 minutes. "I can't change the queue myself, but I can find out how long it's likely to be, and let the GP know your situation. I'll come straight back and tell you what they say. Would that help?"
This answer works because it focuses on what you can change. As a student you can't move her up the queue, but you can stop her feeling ignored, and that is usually what the anger is about. Asking what worries her most shows that the main problem is the lunch, not the wait itself. And when she blames the GP, you neither agree nor defend them, because you've only heard one side.
Saying no
In some stations, the person wants something you can't give them: test results from a student, antibiotics they don't need, or information about a relative that's confidential. Don't give in just to end the awkwardness, and don't refuse and leave it there. Do three things instead:
- Find out why they're asking. There's usually a worry behind the request. The patient asking for his results early may be frightened of what they'll show.
- Say no clearly, and give the reason. "I'm not able to give you your results, because I'm a student and I couldn't explain them properly or answer your questions."
- Offer what you can do. "What I can do is let the doctor know you're anxious to hear, and stay with you until they're ready."
If the person becomes abusive, set one calm boundary: "I really want to help, and I can do that best if we can talk calmly." Actors are often briefed to settle once you've stayed polite but firm.
Confronting a friend or colleague
In these stations, you act out the professionalism questions from the Ethical Questions module. The approach is the same (find out what happened, put patient safety first, raise it with them, escalate if needed, offer support), but in a role play, how you say it matters as much as what you say.
- Ask before you accuse. Start with what you noticed and a question: "I saw the photo you posted from the ward. Did you realise there's a patient in the background?" Candidates who have all the right points but deliver them as a lecture score badly.
- Expect them to bargain. The actor will often say something like "If I delete it, you won't tell anyone, will you?" Don't agree to anything that leaves the problem unresolved, and don't threaten them with the GMC either.
- Be clear about what happens next, and offer support. Encourage them to tell their supervisor themselves, and offer to go with them.
What's next
The next lesson covers supporting someone who is struggling, where the skill is listening rather than solving.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle role play questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.