Ethics·Lesson 3.5·14 min read
Knowledge
What are knowledge questions?
Many decisions in medicine aren't a matter of opinion, because the law or the GMC has already settled them. For example, there are rules on who can consent to treatment, when confidential information can be shared, and what a doctor can do at the end of a patient's life. Knowledge questions ask you to explain a legal or ethical concept such as these, rather than respond to a situation. You aren't expected to know medical law like a lawyer. However, a few areas are asked about often, and interviewers expect you to know the facts in those areas precisely. Vague knowledge of the law often leads to a poor score in the station, because it's obvious to the interviewer when you're unsure.
Examples of knowledge questions
Some knowledge questions ask for the facts directly:
- "What is Gillick competence?"
- "When can a doctor break confidentiality?"
Sometimes the knowledge is embedded in another type of question, for example:
- "A 13-year-old asks for contraception and doesn't want her parents told. What do you do?"
This looks like a dilemma between her confidentiality and her parents' right to know, but at its core it's a question about the law: Gillick competence and the Fraser guidelines decide whether a doctor can prescribe to an under-16 without telling her parents. Without that knowledge, you can weigh both sides perfectly and still conclude, wrongly, that the doctor must tell them. The worked station later in this lesson is another example, where the answer depends on the law on capacity.
Before we look at how to answer these questions, let's go over the key concepts that come up most often.
Consent and capacity
Consent is a patient's permission for treatment. It's the topic interviewers most expect you to know precisely, because almost every clinical scenario depends on it.
Valid consent
Consent only counts if three things are true:
- 1.The patient has capacity to make this decision (see below).
- 2.They've been properly informed. That means the risks, benefits and alternatives, including doing nothing. Since the Montgomery case (2015), doctors must mention any risk that a reasonable person in the patient's position, or this particular patient, would think significant. Mrs Montgomery, who had diabetes, wasn't told about a 9–10% risk of her baby's shoulders getting stuck during birth, because her doctor thought the chance of serious harm was very small, and that women who were told would ask for a caesarean. The Supreme Court ruled that what matters is what's significant to the patient, not what doctors usually say. Before this, what to tell patients was judged by what a responsible body of doctors would do (the Bolam test).
- 3.It's voluntary. No pressure from family, staff or anyone else.
The exception is an emergency: if a patient can't consent and treatment can't wait, doctors treat in their best interests.
Capacity
Capacity is whether someone can make a particular decision for themselves. In England and Wales, it's set out in the Mental Capacity Act 2005, and Scotland and Northern Ireland have similar laws of their own. Two features are often misunderstood. It's decision-specific: someone with dementia may be able to choose what to eat, but not whether to have surgery. And it's time-specific: someone confused by an infection today may have capacity next week.
To assess it, ask whether the person can:
- understand the information about the decision
- retain it long enough to decide
- use and weigh it to reach a decision
- communicate their decision, by any means
If they can't do one of these because of something affecting how their mind or brain works, such as dementia, a brain injury or delirium, they lack capacity for that decision.
The Act also sets out five principles, and these three matter most in interviews:
- Presume capacity. It's up to the doctor to show someone lacks it, not up to the patient to prove they have it. Help them decide first, for example by explaining things more simply or choosing a better time.
- An unwise decision isn't proof of lacking capacity. An adult with capacity can refuse life-saving treatment.
- If someone lacks capacity, act in their best interests, choosing the option that restricts their rights and freedom least.
When a patient lacks capacity
Best interests starts from what the patient would want, based on their wishes, values and beliefs, weighed with everything else that matters to their welfare. It isn't what the doctor or family would choose. Before deciding, check two things:
- An advance decision. A refusal of treatment the patient made while they had capacity. If it's valid and applies to the situation, it's legally binding, even if the patient will die without treatment. To refuse life-saving treatment, it must be in writing, signed and witnessed, and must say that it applies even if life is at risk. A signed and witnessed card refusing blood, such as those carried by Jehovah's Witnesses, must be respected. If there's real doubt about whether a refusal exists or applies, doctors can give life-saving treatment while they find out.
- A Lasting Power of Attorney (health and welfare). Someone the patient chose, while they had capacity, to make health decisions for them.
Without either, families don't decide. Their role is to tell the team what the patient would have wanted. If people can't agree, the decision can go to the Court of Protection.
Children and consent
Children's consent works differently depending on age:
| Age | Can they consent? | Can they refuse? |
|---|---|---|
| Under 16 | Yes, if they're Gillick competent | Their refusal carries real weight, but can be overruled, ultimately by a court, if it risks death or serious permanent harm |
| 16–17 | Presumed able to consent, like adults | Can be overruled by a court in the same way |
| 18 and over | Yes, as adults | Yes, even if the decision seems unwise |
This is the law in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. In Scotland, 16 and 17-year-olds are treated as adults, and parents can't override a competent under-16's refusal.
Young people can consent before they can fully refuse. The law lets them accept treatment that's in their interests more readily than it lets them turn down treatment that would save their life.
Gillick competence
Gillick competence is the test for whether someone under 16 can consent to their own treatment. They can if they're mature enough to understand, retain and weigh up the information, and communicate a decision, much like the adult test for capacity. It's decision-specific too: a 13-year-old might be competent to consent to a vaccine but not to major surgery. Even when they're competent, encourage them to involve their parents, where it's safe to.
The Fraser guidelines
Both names come from the same 1985 case, brought by Victoria Gillick, a mother who objected to doctors giving contraception to under-16s without parental consent. Gillick competence is the general test. The Fraser guidelines, set out by Lord Fraser in the judgment, apply specifically to contraception and sexual health. A doctor can give contraceptive advice or treatment to an under-16 without their parents knowing if all five of these conditions are met:
- 1.They understand the advice.
- 2.They can't be persuaded to tell their parents.
- 3.They're likely to start or continue having sex, with or without contraception.
- 4.Their physical or mental health is likely to suffer without treatment.
- 5.It's in their best interests to receive the advice or treatment without parental consent.
Safeguarding always sits alongside this. The doctor should gently explore whether the young person is at risk of exploitation or abuse, such as a much older partner or pressure to have sex. Sexual activity involving a child under 13 should usually trigger child protection procedures, because under-13s can't legally consent to sex.
When parents and doctors disagree
Parents usually make decisions for young children, but those decisions must be in the child's best interests. If parents refuse treatment a child needs, such as Jehovah's Witness parents refusing a blood transfusion, doctors can ask a court to decide. In an emergency, they can give life-saving treatment without waiting. It works the other way too: parents can't insist on treatment doctors believe isn't in the child's interests, as in the Charlie Gard case, where the courts decided. The child's interests come first, not the parents' wishes.
Confidentiality
Patients only tell doctors everything if they trust them to keep it private, and without the full picture, doctors can't keep them safe. So confidentiality is a strong duty, but it isn't absolute. Under the law and GMC guidance, a doctor may share information when:
- The patient consents.
- The law requires it. For example, a court order; notifiable diseases such as TB or measles, reported to the public health team; or, in England and Wales, FGM in a girl under 18, reported to the police.
- It's in the public interest, to prevent a risk of death or serious harm to others. A patient who keeps driving when they're medically unfit is the classic case. The doctor explains that it's the patient's legal duty to tell the DVLA and tries to persuade them. If they carry on driving, the doctor tells them they'll inform the DVLA, then does.
- A patient has a gunshot wound, or a knife wound from an attack. The police are told so they can assess the risk to others, usually without naming the patient at first.
- Safeguarding requires it, for a child or an adult at risk of abuse or neglect.
There is a difference between "must" and "may". When the law requires disclosure, the doctor must share. In the public interest, it's a judgement: a doctor may tell the partner of a patient with HIV who refuses to tell them, but isn't required to, and should first try to persuade the patient. And once a doctor has decided to disclose, they shouldn't ask the patient's permission, since they'd disclose anyway. They tell the patient what they're going to do, where it's safe to.
When a doctor does share information, they share the minimum necessary and record their reasoning.
The most common mistake is to say "I'd tell the family." Family members have no automatic right to information about an adult with capacity, however close they are.
Four areas of law to know precisely
These come up less often, but when they do, you need to know the facts precisely. For abortion and end-of-life questions, interviewers rarely want your personal view. They want the law, the people affected and an understanding of both sides.
Abortion
- Under the Abortion Act 1967 (England, Wales and Scotland), two doctors must agree that a legal ground applies.
- The most common ground has a 24-week limit. There's no limit where there's a risk to the woman's life, a risk of grave permanent injury, or a serious fetal abnormality.
- Since April 2026, a woman in England and Wales who ends her own pregnancy no longer commits a criminal offence. The rules for doctors and everyone else are unchanged.
- Doctors can conscientiously object and decline to take part, except where treatment is needed to save a life or prevent grave permanent injury. Their objection mustn't stop the patient getting care, so they must make sure the patient can see another doctor.
- Northern Ireland has had different law since 2020, with abortion available on request up to 12 weeks.
DNACPR
- A "do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation" decision is about CPR only. All other treatment and care continue. This is the most common misconception.
- Doctors don't have to offer CPR that won't work, but the patient, or those close to them, should normally be involved early and honestly.
- It's often recorded as part of a wider plan for emergency care, such as a ReSPECT form.
Organ donation
- All four UK nations have a soft opt-out system: adults are treated as willing donors unless they've opted out.
- "Soft" means families are always consulted. In practice, donation doesn't go ahead if the family objects, even when the person had registered to donate.
- Some groups are excluded from deemed consent. In England, that's under-18s, people who lacked the capacity to understand the system, visitors, and people who had lived in England for less than 12 months before they died.
End of life
Four things are often confused. Two are legal, and two aren't:
- Euthanasia: a doctor deliberately ends a patient's life, for example with a lethal injection. Illegal: it would be murder.
- Assisted suicide (what's usually meant by "assisted dying"): the patient takes a lethal drug themselves, with someone's help. Illegal: in England and Wales it carries up to 14 years in prison (Suicide Act 1961).
- Withdrawing or withholding treatment that's no longer in the patient's best interests, such as a ventilator. Legal, and not euthanasia, because the illness causes death, not the doctor (Airedale NHS Trust v Bland, 1993).
- Pain relief that may shorten life. Legal if the aim is to relieve suffering, not to end life. This is known as the doctrine of double effect.
The law on assisted dying has come close to changing. MPs backed a bill for England and Wales in 2025, but it ran out of time in the House of Lords in April 2026. Scotland's Parliament rejected a bill in March 2026, and MPs voted down a new bill in September 2026. The arguments for are autonomy and dying with dignity. The arguments against are protecting vulnerable people from pressure, and the role of good palliative care. Whatever your view, as a doctor you follow the law as it stands.
How to answer: define, explain, example
Once you know the concepts, answering a direct knowledge question is simple, because there's nothing to weigh up. Define the term in a sentence, explain how it works and why it matters, then give an example. For "What is capacity?":
"Capacity is the ability to make a particular decision. A patient has it if they can understand the information, retain it, weigh it up and communicate a choice. It's judged for each decision, so someone with dementia might be able to choose what to eat but not to refuse an operation."
Knowledge questions often turn into a scenario: "...and what would you do here?" When that happens, use the knowledge to reach a decision, rather than just reciting it. The station below shows what that looks like. And if you don't know a law, don't invent one. Say that you aren't certain and what you'd expect it to say, and get back to your reasoning.
A worked station: consent and capacity
This is the Medical Schools Council's own sample ethics station, so it closely reflects what medical schools are looking for.
"You're a doctor on a surgical ward. An elderly man needs a below-knee amputation; every other treatment has failed. He's confused and doesn't recognise his family, but when asked, he firmly says 'No'. You're unsure whether he has capacity. One son agrees with him; the other wants the surgery. How would you approach this?"
A strong answer:
"First, this isn't a decision I'd make alone. I'd involve my seniors and the wider team from the start.
The key question is whether he has capacity for this decision. Before concluding he doesn't, I'd want to know why he's confused. Older patients in hospital often become suddenly confused because of something treatable, like an infection, pain, dehydration or a medication. Treating the cause could clear the confusion, so I'd ask whether the decision can safely wait.
If he has capacity, I'd respect his refusal, even if it seems unwise, make sure he understands the consequences, and keep supporting him. If he lacks capacity, we'd decide in his best interests, giving great weight to what he would have wanted. I'd check whether he made an advance decision while he had capacity, or gave someone Lasting Power of Attorney, a legal right to make health decisions for him. I'd consult both sons and the team, and choose the least restrictive option.
With the family, I'd say: 'This must be incredibly hard for you both. You clearly both want what's best for your dad.' And I'd ask what he would have wanted, not what they want."
In pillar terms, this station is autonomy against beneficence, and capacity is what decides between them: with capacity his refusal stands, and without it the team acts in his best interests. This answer is strong because it recognises that the confusion might be temporary. Many candidates immediately conclude that he lacks capacity. Candidates also often forget that neither son gets to decide, unless one of them holds a health and welfare Lasting Power of Attorney. If the family and team can't agree, the decision can ultimately go to the Court of Protection. The decision is never made by a vote among the family.
What's next
That's the end of the Ethical Questions module. You now have an approach for each type of ethics question, and the knowledge the scenarios depend on. The next module covers role play and communication stations.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle ethics questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.