Menu

Personal Reflection·Lesson 8.2·6 min read

Mistakes, Weaknesses and Feedback

Every doctor makes mistakes, has things they aren't good at, and is given feedback on their work throughout their career. A doctor who can't admit to these puts patients at risk, because hidden problems don't get fixed. Medical schools therefore ask about your own mistakes and weaknesses, to see whether you can be honest about them and whether you do something about them. This lesson covers how to answer questions about your weaknesses, your mistakes and failures, and feedback you've received.

Section 8.2.1

Examples of these questions

These questions can ask about a weakness in general, or about a particular time when something went wrong. For example:

  • "What is your biggest weakness?"
  • "Tell me about a time you made a mistake. What did you learn from it?"
  • "Tell me about a time you were given feedback that you didn't agree with."
Section 8.2.2

Choosing a weakness

The hardest part of a weakness question is deciding which weakness to talk about. Many applicants choose something that isn't a weakness at all, such as "I work too hard" or "I care too much", and interviewers recognise this as avoiding the question. A good weakness to talk about has three features:

  1. 1.It's real. It should be something that has caused you a problem, and you should be able to say what the problem was.
  2. 2.It can be improved. Choose a weakness that you can do something about. Avoid a fixed part of your personality, such as being shy, and pick something you could get better at with practice, such as speaking in front of a group or asking for help when you need it.
  3. 3.It wouldn't make you unsafe as a doctor. Some weaknesses are too close to what the job requires, and naming one would make an interviewer doubt that you're suited to medicine. Avoid weaknesses such as poor attention to detail, disliking teamwork or struggling to accept criticism.

A useful test is to imagine a senior doctor hearing your answer. They should think that the weakness is fixable, and that you are already working towards fixing it.

Section 8.2.3

How to answer a weakness question

Once you've chosen your weakness, we recommend covering three things in your answer:

  1. 1.Name the weakness, and say how it affects you. Be specific about when it happens and what goes wrong.
  2. 2.Say why it would matter in medicine. This shows that you understand the job, and that you've thought about the weakness seriously.
  3. 3.Say what you're doing about it. Describe the steps you've taken, and how much progress you've made. It's fine to say that you're still working on it, and this is more believable than claiming you've fixed it.
Section 8.2.4

A worked example

"What is your biggest weakness?"

Here is a strong answer, following the three steps:

  1. 1.The weakness. "One quality I'm working on is public speaking. I communicate well one-to-one, but I can feel nervous when speaking to larger groups, which sometimes affects how clearly I get my points across."
  2. 2.Why it matters in medicine. "In medicine, this could be a problem because doctors often have to present clinical information on ward rounds, teach others, or explain complex ideas clearly to patients and families."
  3. 3.What I'm doing about it. "To improve, I've been deliberately putting myself in situations that challenge me. For example, I've volunteered to present in class and taken part in debate workshops at school. I'm starting to feel more confident structuring my thoughts under pressure, and I plan to continue building this skill at university by joining societies that involve communication."

This answer names a weakness that is real, and says when it happens and what effect it has. It then explains why the weakness would matter for a doctor, which shows that the candidate has thought about it. Most of the answer is about what the candidate is doing to improve, with specific examples, and it's honest that the work isn't finished.

Section 8.2.5

Mistakes and failures

Questions about a mistake or a failure ask for an example, so you can use the STARR structure from the last lesson. The reflection is still the most important part, but for these questions there are three more things to get right:

  • Choose a small, real mistake. Interviewers are marking your reflection and not the mistake, so you don't need a dramatic one. Forgetting a commitment, misjudging how long something would take or handling a disagreement badly all work well.
  • Take responsibility for it. Say plainly what you did wrong, without blaming other people or the circumstances. If someone else pointed the mistake out to you, say so, because it's more honest than suggesting you noticed it yourself.
  • Say what you now do differently. "I'm more careful now" is too vague to show anything. Describe the specific habit you've changed, such as checking your calendar every evening or asking for help earlier.
Section 8.2.6

Feedback and criticism

Some questions ask about a time you were given feedback or criticism, and the hardest version is feedback that you disagreed with. Many applicants spend the answer proving that they were right, but interviewers are assessing how you respond to feedback, not who was right.

A strong answer says what the feedback was, without softening it, and admits how you first reacted. It then explains how you worked out whether the feedback was fair, for example by asking someone else for their view or by watching what happened the next time. Finish with what you changed as a result. It also helps to accept that the feedback was at least partly right, because it usually is.

Section 8.2.7

What's next

The next lesson covers the opposite kind of question: your strengths, and the qualities that make a good doctor.

Put Your Knowledge to the Test

Tackle reflection questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.

Try a Question