NHS & Topical Issues·Lesson 10.6·3 min read
Landmark Cases
Some interview questions ask about a well-known case, and what the NHS learned from it. You aren't expected to know every detail, but you should be able to say what happened and what changed as a result. This lesson covers five cases that come up.
Section 10.6.1
Examples of these questions
These questions usually name the case. For example:
- "What do you know about the Lucy Letby case?"
- "What lessons came from the Harold Shipman case?"
- "What was the Charlie Gard case about?"
Section 10.6.2
The cases
- Charlie Gard. Charlie Gard was a baby with a rare mitochondrial disease, whose parents wanted him to have experimental treatment overseas. His hospital asked the court for permission to withdraw ventilation. The court applied the "best interests" test, weighing a small chance of improvement against the burdens of intensive care and his irreversible brain injury. The case shows that the child's welfare comes first, and that when parents and doctors disagree, the court decides.
- Hadiza Bawa-Garba. Dr Bawa-Garba was a paediatric trainee who was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter after a child died from sepsis, on a shift with several failings in the system around her. The case started a debate about "just culture", which means separating individual error from system failings. It was followed by the Williams Review, which looked at when healthcare staff should be prosecuted and how to protect learning after harm.
- Harold Shipman. Harold Shipman was a GP who was convicted of murdering 15 patients, and the inquiry that followed concluded that he had killed at least 215. The reforms since then include the independent review of every death by a medical examiner or a coroner, tighter rules on controlled drugs, and revalidation, in which doctors have to show regularly that they are fit to practise.
- Lucy Letby. Lucy Letby was a neonatal nurse who was convicted in 2023 and 2024 of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others. A public inquiry, the Thirlwall Inquiry, reported in September 2026 on how concerns were raised and handled, and on the lessons for whistleblowing and escalation.
- The MMR scandal. A study, which was later retracted, suggested a link between the MMR vaccine and autism, and its lead author was removed from the medical register. Large studies have found no causal link, and the scientific consensus is that MMR is safe and effective. However, vaccine uptake fell after the study, and measles returned.
Section 10.6.3
What's next
That's the end of the NHS & Topical Issues module. The next module covers data interpretation.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle topical questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.