Menu

Role Play & Communication·Lesson 4.6·6 min read

Persuading and Taking a History

This lesson covers the last two types of role play: persuading someone to make a change, and taking a history. We'll start with persuading.

Section 4.6.1

What are persuading stations?

Doctors often need patients to change something, such as stopping smoking, taking a medicine or coming in for a scan. They can't make anyone do it, and pushing people tends to make them more resistant. Persuading stations test whether you can encourage a change while leaving the decision with the person. You're usually given the facts you need, such as the risks of carrying on, so you're being tested on how you use them.

Section 4.6.2

Examples of persuading stations

The change is usually about someone's health, and the person may be a patient or a friend:

  • "You are a doctor. A patient who smokes regularly needs knee surgery. Persuade him to stop smoking, and explain the risks if he doesn't."
  • "Your friend has started vaping heavily. Talk to them about it."
  • "A patient has stopped taking her tablets and is using a herbal remedy instead. Talk to her."
Section 4.6.3

Explore, inform, support, respect

For persuading stations, we recommend four steps: explore, inform, support, respect.

  1. 1.Explore. People change for their own reasons, not yours, so you need to find out what theirs are. Ask permission to talk about it, then ask what they know, what they get out of the habit, and what worries them about changing. Sometimes there's a firm belief behind their choice, such as having read online that a herbal remedy works better than their tablets. Ask where it came from and take it seriously, because people stop listening once they feel laughed at.
  2. 2.Inform. Ask before you give information: "Would it be okay if I shared what we know about smoking and surgery?" Then give the key risks and benefits in small chunks, picking the ones that matter to them. Use the facts on your brief, and don't make up medical details.
  3. 3.Support. Someone can want to change and still find it hard. Find out what would get in the way, and offer something that makes it easier, such as a stop smoking service or a plan for the first step.
  4. 4.Respect. Give a clear recommendation, then leave the decision with them. Let them know they can come back to it, and offer to talk again.

In these stations, a realistic aim is for the person to agree to think about it. Pushing for a promise ("So you'll quit, then?") will lead to a poor score in the station.

Section 4.6.4

A worked example

"You are a doctor. A patient who smokes regularly needs knee surgery. Persuade him to stop smoking, and explain the risks if he doesn't."

  1. 1.Explore. "Would it be okay if we talked about your smoking before the operation? … What do you know about how smoking affects surgery?" He doesn't know much. "And what does smoking do for you?" He says it helps with stress, and he's tried to stop before and couldn't.
  2. 2.Inform. "Would it be okay if I shared what we know? Smoking raises the risk of wound infections, slower healing and breathing problems during the operation. Stopping beforehand lowers those risks, so you'd be likely to get back on your feet sooner."
  3. 3.Support. "You said it was hard last time. Did you have any help? There's a free local stop smoking service, and nicotine patches can make it easier. Would you like me to refer you?"
  4. 4.Respect. "My advice would be to stop before the operation, but it's your decision. Would you be willing to think about it? We can talk again at your next appointment."

This answer finds out why he smokes and what stopped him last time, and then offers help with that. The information is tied to what he cares about, which is recovering quickly. And it ends with a clear recommendation but no pressure.

Section 4.6.5

Taking a history

The last type of role play is taking a history. In the rest of this module, you've been responding to a problem or passing on information. In a history-taking station, you gather information. A patient comes in with a problem, and you ask questions to build up the full picture. Doctors do this at the start of almost every consultation. It's less common for school leavers, but it does come up. For example:

  • "You're a medical student in A&E. Take a history from a patient with wrist pain."

A history is taken in a set order, so that nothing important gets missed:

  1. 1.Open question: "What's brought you in today?" Then let them talk.
  2. 2.The main problem: when it started, what it's like, what makes it better or worse.
  3. 3.Past medical history: other conditions and operations.
  4. 4.Family history: conditions that run in the family.
  5. 5.Medicines and allergies.
  6. 6.Social history: smoking, alcohol, work, home life, and how the problem is affecting them.

Before you finish, ask what they think is going on, what's worrying them, and what they're hoping for. Then summarise what they've told you. Nobody expects a complete history at an interview. You're being marked on listening and working through it logically, not on medical knowledge.

Section 4.6.6

What's next

That's the end of the Role Play & Communication module. The best way to improve from here is to practise out loud with someone playing the other person. The next module covers what doctors do, and what a career in medicine involves.

Put Your Knowledge to the Test

Tackle role play questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.

Try a Question