Menu
What Interviewers Are Looking For

Getting Started·Lesson 1.3·7 min read

What Interviewers Are Looking For

Many applicants prepare for interviews by learning answers to common questions. But interviewers aren't checking your answers against a list of correct ones. They are looking for certain qualities, and each question is a way of finding out whether you have them. This lesson covers what those qualities are, the types of question used to assess them, and how your answers are marked.

Section 1.3.1

What medical schools want to know

As we covered in the last lesson, medical schools want to give their places to people who will finish the course and become safe, capable doctors. In an interview, this comes down to three questions:

  1. 1.Will you finish the degree? Medicine is a long and demanding course. Interviewers look for motivation that is based on a realistic understanding of the job, and for resilience when things get difficult.
  2. 2.Will you be safe with patients? Interviewers look for honesty, a willingness to admit mistakes, and an understanding that patient safety comes first.
  3. 3.Will you be a good doctor? Interviewers look for clear communication and good listening, empathy and respect for other people, sound reasoning, teamwork, and the ability to reflect on your own performance.

These qualities come from a list of attributes that all UK medical schools have agreed through the Medical Schools Council, and schools base their interviews on them. Your grades and UCAT score have already shown your academic ability, so the interview isn't a test of what you know. It assesses how you think and how you behave.

Section 1.3.2

The types of question

To find out whether you have these qualities, interviewers use eleven different types of question. Although the types look very different from each other, each one assesses part of the three questions above from a different angle:

TypeWhat you're askedWhat it shows
MotivationWhy medicine, and why this medical schoolThat your decision is informed and realistic
EthicsA scenario where the right action isn't obviousReasoning, honesty and putting patient safety first
Role playA conversation with an actorCommunication, listening and empathy
Personal reflectionA time you failed, led or were challengedSelf-awareness, and the ability to learn from experience
Work experienceWhat you saw, and what you learned from itA realistic understanding of the job
Personal statementThe experiences you wrote about in your applicationThat your experiences are real, and that you've reflected on them
TeamworkYour experience of working with others, or a live group taskThat you work well with other people
NHS and current issuesA policy or a news story in healthcareAwareness of how healthcare works, and balanced reasoning
Medicine as a careerTraining, and the realities of the jobThat you know what you're applying for
Data interpretationA graph, a table or a calculationCareful reasoning with numbers
Abstract tasksAn unusual task, such as describing an imageClear thinking and communication under pressure

No school uses all eleven types. Schools also give their stations different names, and some combine two types in one station. Sheffield, for example, has stations called "Good medical practice" and "Attitudes and values", which cover the same ground as ethics and personal reflection. So if you prepare for all eleven types, you'll be ready for most of what your schools ask, whatever they call their stations. Most of the modules in our curriculum will cover one question type each, and show you how to approach the common questions of that type effectively.

Section 1.3.3

How your answers are marked

In an MMI, the interviewer at each station marks your answer against a mark sheet written for that station. They give you a score, often out of 10 or 15, and at some schools they also give an overall judgement of how you performed. Your scores from each station are then added up to give your total. The mark sheets differ between schools, but four things affect your score at many of them:

  • Only what you say can be marked. Interviewers can't give credit for something you understood but didn't say. If an experience taught you something, say what it taught you, and say it early in your answer in case you run out of time.
  • Communication is marked as well as content. At some schools it has its own mark at every station. At Imperial, each station is marked out of 6 for content and 4 for communication.
  • Being prompted can lower your score. Try to cover the main points yourself, before the interviewer has to ask.
  • Rehearsed answers can score lower. Interviewers want answers that are genuine, and they may ask for a different example if yours sounds memorised.
Section 1.3.4

How to answer well

Each type of question has its own framework, which we'll cover in the later modules. However, there are four things you should do in every answer, whatever the question:

  • Answer the question you were asked. A common mistake is giving an answer you prepared for a similar question. Listen to the whole question, and ask for it to be repeated if you need to.
  • Give evidence for what you say. "I'm a good communicator" can't be marked, but a specific example can. Then say what you learned from it, because interviewers are more interested in your reflection on an experience than in the experience itself.
  • Speak for one to two minutes. Make two to four points in a clear order, then stop. If the interviewer wants more, they'll ask.
  • Don't guess when you don't know. Say what you do know, or how you'd work it out. Asking for a moment to think is fine.
Section 1.3.5

How interviewers behave

Interviewers are given instructions on how to run their station, and they follow them with every candidate. Two of the things they're told to do can be unsettling if you aren't expecting them:

  • They ask follow-up questions and challenge your answers. These are often planned in advance. In an ethics station, the interviewer may argue against your view whichever side you take. This doesn't mean your answer was wrong, and you don't need to change it unless they give you a good reason.
  • They may not react at all. Many interviewers are told to stay neutral, so they won't nod, smile or tell you how you're doing, and some will be writing notes while you speak. A quiet interviewer doesn't mean the station is going badly.
Section 1.3.6

Red flags

Some schools let interviewers raise a "red flag" about a candidate, separately from their score. A red flag is for a serious concern about someone's attitude, such as a discriminatory comment, dishonesty, or being rude to staff or other applicants. It isn't raised for a weak answer, which only loses you marks in that station. But a red flag can stop you getting an offer even if your overall score is high. Your behaviour is also assessed for the whole time you're there, not only inside the stations.

Section 1.3.7

What's next

The next lesson covers how to prepare: what to do before you're invited, how to practise, and what to do on the day.