Abstract Tasks·Lesson 13.1·11 min read
Abstract Tasks
Dentists regularly face situations they haven't met before, where there is no prepared answer and they have to work out an approach on the spot. Some dental schools test this with an unusual task, such as talking someone through tying a shoelace or estimating a number that nobody could know. These tasks are chosen so that you can't rehearse an answer in advance. This lesson covers some of the tasks you might be given, and how to approach each one.
What you might be given
Abstract tasks vary a lot between schools, but most are one of four kinds:
- Giving instructions. "Instruct me to tie my shoelaces, without using any hand gestures."
- Describing a picture. "Describe this picture as if you were describing it to someone who can't see it."
- Prioritising. "You have three hours and six things to do. Rank them in order of priority."
- An unusual question. "How would you estimate the number of lamp posts in London?"
Some dental schools have also set hands-on tasks, such as origami or threading, and these are covered in the Manual Dexterity module.
How to approach any abstract task
These tasks rarely have one correct answer, and you can often do well without finishing them. Interviewers are watching how you go about the task, so we recommend three things whichever kind you're given:
- 1.Say your plan first. Tell the interviewer how you're going to approach the task before you begin.
- 2.Think out loud. The interviewer can only give you credit for reasoning that they hear.
- 3.Change your approach when you need to. If something isn't working, say so calmly and try another way.
Many of these stations end with a question such as "How do you think that went?" or "Why do you think we asked you to do this?" Give an honest answer, including what you would do differently, and link the task to something a dentist does.
Below, we'll go through an example of each of the four kinds of task, to give you a sense of what they involve and how you can approach them effectively.
Giving instructions
In a giving instructions task, you have to talk the interviewer through a simple practical task, such as tying a shoelace or following a route on a map. You usually aren't allowed to gesture or demonstrate, so everything depends on how clearly you explain each step. The interviewer does exactly what you say, and if an instruction could be understood in two ways, they may deliberately choose the wrong one, so expect the task to go wrong at some point. They want to see that your instructions get clearer as you go, and that you stay patient. We recommend four things:
- Set up first. Say what you're going to do together, and ask about the starting position, such as which hand they use.
- Give one action at a time. Say which hand, which part and which direction, and avoid words they might not know.
- Check after each step. Ask "What can you see now?" and not "Does that make sense?", because most people answer yes to the second whether or not they understood.
- Take responsibility when it goes wrong. Go back to the last point that was right, and explain the step in different words.
For example, when the interviewer has made a mistake, you could say:
"That was my fault, I wasn't clear. Let's undo that and go back to the X shape, and I'll explain it another way."
Bristol has in the past asked applicants to prepare instructions for a simple task of their own choice, to be explained in words alone, and the same four things apply.
Describing a picture
In a picture task, you're shown a photograph or a drawing and asked to describe it out loud. This task tests whether you can observe carefully and pass on what you see in an organised way, as a dentist does when referring a patient to a colleague by letter or over the phone. Describe the picture as if the interviewer can't see it, even when they can. In some versions they have to draw what you describe, and in others you write your description down. You won't have time to cover everything, so going through the picture in a clear order is more important than mentioning every detail. The picture can be an everyday scene or a clinical photograph, and each has its own framework.
An everyday scene
You might be shown a street, a painting or a crowded beach. We recommend four steps:
- 1.Overview. Say what the picture shows in one sentence, before any detail, such as "a town square on a sunny day".
- 2.Details. Divide the picture into groups, such as the buildings, the people, the sky and the foreground. For each group, describe its general appearance and then add the finer detail. Go through the groups in a fixed order, such as foreground to background or left to right, and don't jump between them.
- 3.Context. Add anything else you've noticed that the groups didn't cover.
- 4.Limitations. Say what the picture can't tell you, such as what happened before or after it was taken, the sounds, the temperature or the story behind the scene.
For a photograph of a market, you could begin:
"This photograph shows an outdoor fruit and vegetable stall, where a customer is buying from a vendor. In the foreground there are boxes of oranges, with green leafy vegetables to the left and rows of tomatoes behind them. The customer is on the left, wearing a dark jacket with yellow high-visibility strips and a face mask, and is reaching forward with one hand."
A clinical photograph
You might instead be shown a photograph of an injury or a disease, which may be of the face or mouth but can be of any part of the body. Describe it from the patient's side, so say "the patient's left leg" and not "the leg on the right of the photo". Say what you can see, and leave what you think it means until the end. For example, "red and swollen" is a description, whereas "infected" is an interpretation.
We recommend five steps:
- 1.Location. Name the body part, and say where on it the abnormality is and which side it's on.
- 2.The abnormality. Describe its size, shape, edges, depth and general appearance.
- 3.The surrounding area. Mention anything around the main finding, such as bruising, blistering, redness or swelling.
- 4.Limitations. Say what the photograph can't tell you, such as how painful the area is, whether it's warm, and how the patient is feeling overall.
- 5.Impression. Finish with a brief summary of what you're seeing and what it might represent. You aren't expected to make a diagnosis.
You can use medical terms, but only if you're confident with them, because using a term wrongly gives a poor impression. The most useful terms are shown in the table below:
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Medial | Towards the midline of the body |
| Lateral | Away from the midline |
| Superior | Above |
| Inferior | Below |
| Unilateral | Affecting one side |
| Bilateral | Affecting both sides |
For a photograph of a patient with a swollen eye, you could say:
"This is a close-up photograph of the upper face of an adult, showing both eyes and the bridge of the nose. The main abnormality is on the left side. The left upper eyelid is very swollen and looks completely closed, so I can't see the left eye at all. The swelling also involves the lower eyelid and spreads onto the upper part of the left cheek. The skin over the swollen area looks intact, with a slight redness, and I can't see any cuts, bruising or discharge. The right eye is open and looks normal. Because this is a single photograph, I can't tell how painful the area is, whether it's warm, or how long it has been there. In summary, this is a unilateral, left-sided swelling around the eye, with intact skin and no open wound visible."
Prioritising
In a prioritising task, you're given a list of tasks or items and a limit, such as six things to do in three hours or a small bag to pack, and asked to put them in order. There are always more than you have time or space for, so you have to decide what comes first and what gets left out. Dentists make this kind of decision too, for example when a patient in pain needs to be seen on a day that is already fully booked. There is usually more than one sensible order, so the reasons you give matter more than the order itself. We recommend three things:
- Say how you're deciding before you give your order. Useful things to consider are whether a task has a deadline today, what happens if it isn't done, whether it can be moved, and whether someone is relying on you.
- Check that your plan fits. Add up the time or space it needs.
- Deal with what you leave out. Say what you would do about those tasks, such as who you would tell.
Interviewers often challenge your order or add new information. You can change your plan when they do, as long as you explain why. For example, imagine you have three hours and six things to do: a meeting with a lecturer, a life support training session, a student finance form due today, a society lunch, showing a new housemate round and phoning your sibling. You could begin:
"I would sort these by whether they can only happen today, how serious the consequences are if I miss them, and whether somebody else is depending on me. So the meeting with my lecturer comes first, because it was booked two weeks ago and the lecturer is away for a month afterwards."
Unusual questions
Some stations ask a question that seems to have nothing to do with dentistry. It might ask you to estimate something that nobody could know, such as the number of lamp posts in London, or to solve a problem that sounds impossible, such as "How would you move a mountain?" Nobody expects you to know the answer. The interviewer wants to see you break a large problem into smaller steps and reason your way to an answer. We recommend five steps:
- 1.Define the question. Say what you're taking it to mean. For the mountain, that could be how far it has to move and whether it has to stay in one piece.
- 2.Break it into smaller parts. Start from something you know or can work out.
- 3.State your assumptions and work it through. Explain the assumptions you're making, and if you estimate any numbers, use simple ones that are easy to work with.
- 4.Reach an answer. Even if you aren't sure it's right, it's useful to commit to an answer at the end, because it shows that you can follow your reasoning through. For an estimate, that means giving a figure.
- 5.Say where your answer is weakest. Name the assumption you're least sure of.
For the lamp posts question, a strong answer following the five steps would be:
Define the question. "I'll take London to mean the whole city, out to the ends of the Tube lines, and I'll only count street lamps."
Break it into smaller parts. "First I'll work out how big London is. Then I'll estimate how much of it is lit by street lamps, and how much ground one lamp post lights."
State your assumptions and work it through. "The Tube takes roughly two hours to go from one end of London to the other. Assuming it travels at about 30 kilometres an hour, London is about 60 kilometres across. If it's roughly a circle, its radius is 30 kilometres, so its area is about 3 times 30 squared, which is 2,700, or roughly 3,000 square kilometres. A lot of London is buildings, gardens, parks and open land, so I'll assume that about 10% of it is lit by street lamps, which is 300 square kilometres. I'll also assume that one lamp post lights about 500 square metres, which is an area of about 20 metres by 25. A square kilometre is a million square metres, so each square kilometre needs about 2,000 lamp posts."
Reach an answer. "300 square kilometres times 2,000 lamp posts is 600,000. So my estimate is about 600,000 lamp posts."
Say where your answer is weakest. "The assumption I'm least sure of is the 10%, because the centre of London has far more streets than the edges do."
What's next
That's the end of our interview curriculum! Go back and review any lessons you're less sure of, but the most important thing now is to practise as many questions as you can. Answer them out loud, and after each one, reflect on what went well and what you would improve next time.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle abstract questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.