Ethical Questions·Lesson 3.5·11 min read
Knowledge
What are knowledge questions?
Many decisions in dentistry aren't a matter of opinion, because the law or the GDC has already settled them. For example, there are rules on who can consent to treatment, what a patient must be told before they agree to it, and when confidential information can be shared. Knowledge questions ask you to explain a legal or ethical concept such as these, rather than respond to a situation. You aren't expected to know the law like a lawyer. However, a few areas are asked about often, and interviewers expect you to know the facts in those areas precisely. Vague knowledge of the law often leads to a poor score in the station, because it's obvious to the interviewer when you're unsure.
Examples of knowledge questions
Some knowledge questions ask for the facts directly:
- "What is Gillick competence?"
- "Can a child under 16 consent to dental treatment?"
Sometimes the knowledge is embedded in another type of question, for example:
- "The mother of a 17-year-old patient phones the practice and asks whether her son has been attending his check-ups. What would you do?"
This looks like a harmless request from a caring parent, but at its core it's a question about the law: a 17-year-old is owed the same confidentiality as an adult, so the dentist can't tell her without his permission. Without that knowledge, you can handle the mother kindly and still conclude, wrongly, that the dentist should confirm it. The worked station later in this lesson is another example, where the answer depends on the law on consent for children.
Before we look at how to answer these questions, let's go over the key concepts that come up most often.
Consent and capacity
Consent is a patient's permission for treatment. It's the topic interviewers most expect you to know precisely, because almost every clinical scenario depends on it.
Valid consent
Consent is only valid if three things are true:
- 1.The patient has capacity to make this decision (see below).
- 2.They've been properly informed. That means the risks, benefits and alternatives, including doing nothing. Since the Montgomery case (2015), clinicians must mention any risk that a reasonable person in the patient's position, or this particular patient, would think significant. Mrs Montgomery, who had diabetes, wasn't told about a 9–10% risk of her baby's shoulders getting stuck during birth, because her doctor thought the chance of serious harm was very small, and that women who were told would ask for a caesarean. The Supreme Court ruled that what matters is what's significant to the patient, not what clinicians usually say. The case was about a doctor, but the ruling applies to dentists too.
- 3.It's voluntary. No pressure from family, staff or anyone else.
The exception is an emergency: if a patient can't consent and treatment can't wait, clinicians treat in their best interests.
Consent in dentistry: options and costs
In dentistry, being properly informed includes the cost, because many dental patients pay for their treatment. The GDC expects a dentist to explain the options, with the risks, benefits and cost of each, and to give the patient a written treatment plan with the cost on it before treatment starts. A patient who agrees to treatment without knowing what it will cost hasn't given valid consent.
Many practices offer both NHS and private treatment, so the dentist also has to be clear about which is which. The GDC requires dentists to put the patient's interests before their own financial gain, not to mislead a patient into thinking a treatment is only available privately when the NHS provides it, and not to pressure a patient into private treatment.
Cosmetic and elective requests
Some dental treatment is chosen for appearance and isn't needed for the patient's health, such as whitening or straightening mildly crowded teeth. The NHS doesn't fund purely cosmetic treatment, so it is paid for privately. A patient is entitled to choose it once they've had balanced information, which covers what it involves, the cost, the risks, that results can't be guaranteed, and the option of doing nothing. However, a patient can't insist on treatment that the dentist doesn't think is appropriate, so a dentist can decline a request such as removing healthy teeth.
Tooth whitening is also controlled by law. It can only be provided by a dentist, or by another registered dental professional on a dentist's prescription. Products stronger than 6% hydrogen peroxide are illegal, and whitening can't be given to anyone under 18, unless the treatment is to treat or prevent disease.
Capacity
Capacity is whether someone can make a particular decision for themselves. In England and Wales, it's set out in the Mental Capacity Act 2005, and Scotland and Northern Ireland have similar laws of their own. Two features of capacity are often misunderstood. Capacity is decision-specific: someone with dementia may be able to choose what to eat, but not whether to have several teeth taken out. And it's time-specific: someone confused by an infection today may have capacity next week.
To assess capacity, ask whether the person can:
- understand the information about the decision
- retain it long enough to decide
- use and weigh it to reach a decision
- communicate their decision, by any means
If they can't do one of these because of something affecting how their mind or brain works, such as dementia or a brain injury, they lack capacity for that decision.
The Act also sets out five principles, and these three matter most in interviews:
- Presume capacity. It's up to the clinician to show someone lacks it, not up to the patient to prove they have it. Help them decide first, for example by explaining things more simply or choosing a better time.
- An unwise decision isn't proof of lacking capacity. An adult with capacity can refuse treatment that their dentist strongly recommends.
- If someone lacks capacity, act in their best interests, choosing the option that restricts their rights and freedom least.
Best interests starts from what the patient would want, based on their wishes, values and beliefs, weighed with everything else that matters to their welfare. Families don't decide for an adult, unless the patient chose one of them to make health decisions under a Lasting Power of Attorney while they still had capacity. Their role is to tell the team what the patient would have wanted.
Children and consent
Children's consent works differently depending on age:
| Age | Can they consent? | Can they refuse? |
|---|---|---|
| Under 16 | Yes, if they're Gillick competent | Their refusal carries real weight, but can be overruled, ultimately by a court, if it risks death or serious permanent harm |
| 16–17 | Presumed able to consent, like adults | Can be overruled by a court in the same way |
| 18 and over | Yes, as adults | Yes, even if the decision seems unwise |
This is the law in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. In Scotland, 16 and 17-year-olds are treated as adults, and parents can't override a competent under-16's refusal.
Gillick competence
Gillick competence is the test for whether someone under 16 can consent to their own treatment. They can if they're mature enough to understand, retain and weigh up the information, and communicate a decision, much like the adult test for capacity. It's decision-specific too: a 14-year-old might be competent to consent to a check-up or a filling but not to an operation under general anaesthetic. Even when they're competent, encourage them to involve their parents, where it's safe to. The name comes from a 1985 court case brought by a mother, Victoria Gillick, about contraception for under-16s, but the test applies to all treatment, including dental treatment.
When parents and dentists disagree
A young child can't consent for themselves, so someone with parental responsibility decides for them, and that decision must be in the child's best interests. Legally, consent from one person with parental responsibility is enough, although it's much better for both parents to agree. If a parent refuses treatment that a child needs, the dentist listens to their reasons, explains, and offers alternatives or a second opinion. The dentist doesn't treat a child by force. In an emergency, such as a swelling that threatens the child's breathing, clinicians can act in the child's best interests, and in rare disputes that can't be resolved, a court can decide.
Dental neglect
If a child is in ongoing pain or has repeated infections, and the treatment they need keeps being refused, it may be dental neglect, which is a safeguarding concern. The dentist speaks to the practice's safeguarding lead and follows the local safeguarding procedures for children. They tell the parent what they are doing and why, unless that would put the child at risk. This is part of the GDC's principle of raising concerns if patients are at risk.
Confidentiality
Patients only tell their dentist everything, such as their medical conditions and the medicines they take, if they trust the dentist to keep it private, and without that information, a dentist can't treat them safely. So confidentiality is a strong duty, and it's one of the GDC's nine principles, but it isn't absolute. A dentist may share information when:
- The patient consents.
- The law requires it, for example under a court order.
- It's in the public interest, to prevent a risk of death or serious harm to others.
- Safeguarding requires it, for a child or an adult at risk of abuse or neglect.
When a dentist does share information, they share the minimum necessary with the right person, and record their reasoning. Inside the practice, information is shared only with the team members who need it to care for the patient, and this applies to something sensitive such as a patient's HIV status.
Parents and family
Family members have no automatic right to information about an adult with capacity, however close they are. Confidentiality covers more than clinical details, so whether someone is a patient at the practice, and whether they came to an appointment, is confidential too.
The same applies to 16 and 17-year-olds, who are presumed to have capacity and can consent to their own dental treatment. If the mother of a 17-year-old asks whether he has been attending, the dentist doesn't confirm or deny it. The dentist explains that the practice can't share information about any patient aged 16 or over without their permission, and suggests that she asks her son, or that he tells the practice he's happy for her to be told. The dentist also asks whether she's worried about something in particular, in case there's a concern about his welfare.
For a 14-year-old, the starting point is different. Parents are normally involved in a 14-year-old's dental care and can generally be given information about it, once the practice has checked that the caller has parental responsibility. But if a 14-year-old is Gillick competent and has asked for something to be kept private, the dentist respects that unless there's a safeguarding concern.
How to answer: define, explain, example
Once you know the concepts, answering a direct knowledge question is simple, because there's nothing to weigh up. Define the term in a sentence, explain how it works and why it matters, then give an example. For "What is capacity?":
"Capacity is the ability to make a particular decision. A patient has it if they can understand the information, retain it, weigh it up and communicate a choice. It's judged for each decision, so someone with dementia might be able to choose what to eat but not to agree to having several teeth taken out."
Knowledge questions often turn into a scenario: "...and what would you do here?" When that happens, use the knowledge to reach a decision, rather than just reciting it. The station below shows what that looks like. If you don't know a law, don't invent one. Say that you aren't certain, say what you'd expect the law to say, and then return to your reasoning.
A worked station: consent for a child
"You are a dentist. You have advised that a six-year-old girl needs several badly decayed teeth taken out, but her father refuses to allow it. How would you handle this situation?"
A strong answer:
"A six-year-old is too young to consent for herself, so the decision belongs to someone with parental responsibility, and it has to be made in her best interests.
I'd start by listening to her father. I'd ask him in private what worries him most, because it might be the general anaesthetic, a belief that baby teeth fall out anyway, or a bad experience of his own. Then I'd explain in plain language why the teeth can't be saved and what is likely to happen if they're left, such as pain, infection and damage to the adult teeth underneath. I'd also ask the girl how her teeth feel, because her view matters even though she can't give consent.
I'd offer him a second opinion or a referral to a children's dental service, and give him written information and time to think. In the meantime, I'd give advice on pain relief and book a review. I wouldn't treat her by force.
If he still refused, and she stayed in pain or kept getting infections, that may be dental neglect, which is a safeguarding concern. I'd speak to the practice's safeguarding lead, and I'd tell him what I was doing and why."
In terms of the pillars, this station sets the father's right to decide for his daughter against beneficence. The law on children's consent decides between them, because a parent's decision has to be in the child's best interests. The answer starts with that law, and then listens before it tries to persuade, because a refusal like this often comes from fear or a misunderstanding. It also keeps the family coming back, which protects the girl better than an argument that ends with them not returning.
The interviewer may follow up in two ways. If you're asked "What if her mother is happy for the extractions to go ahead?", the legal answer is that consent from one person with parental responsibility is enough, but you'd much rather reach agreement than treat against one parent's objection, and you'd ask a senior colleague for advice. If you're asked "She comes back three months later with a swollen face and her father still refuses. What now?", she now has an infection and the refusal has continued, so you treat it as a safeguarding concern and make sure she gets urgent care.
What's next
That's the end of the Ethical Questions module. You now have an approach for each type of ethics question, and the knowledge the scenarios depend on. The next module covers role play stations.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle ethics questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.