Menu
Your Own Mistakes

Ethical Questions·Lesson 3.4·6 min read

Your Own Mistakes

Section 3.4.1

What are questions about your own mistakes?

Every dentist makes mistakes, such as giving the wrong advice, not checking a medical history or writing a note in the wrong patient's record. In these stations, you are told that you have made a mistake and asked to explain what you would do next. You aren't being judged on the error itself. Like professionalism questions, these questions have a right answer, which is to put the patient's safety first and be honest about what happened, even when hiding it would be easier. Covering up a mistake is treated far more seriously than the mistake itself.

Section 3.4.2

Examples of mistake questions

Most of these questions put you in the position of a dentist or dental student, often in a situation where nobody else knows what you did:

  • "You've just realised you gave a patient another patient's aftercare sheet. What would you do?"
  • "You recorded a patient's planned treatment against the wrong tooth. You noticed before anything was done, and nobody knows you wrote it. What do you do?"
  • "A dentist in a rush prescribes an antibiotic without checking for allergies, and the patient has an allergic reaction. What should the dentist do?"
Section 3.4.3

The five steps

For these questions, we recommend five steps. Unlike SPIES, there are no exceptions to the order: patient safety always comes first.

  1. 1.Patient safety first. Stop any further harm, check on the patient, and call for help if needed.
  2. 2.Take responsibility. Be honest about what happened, don't hide it or shift the blame, and tell a senior early.
  3. 3.Tell the patient. Apologise, and explain in plain language what happened, what can be done about any harm, and what will be done to stop it happening again.
  4. 4.Report it. Complete an incident report, so the practice or clinic can stop the same thing happening to someone else.
  5. 5.Reflect and learn. Work out what made the error possible, change what you do, and share what you've learned.

Telling the patient is a professional duty rather than a courtesy. Under the professional duty of candour, which the GDC applies to every dental professional, you must be open with a patient when something goes wrong with their care. The patient is told what happened, receives an apology and is told what will be done about it. That means telling them as soon as possible, not waiting for an investigation to finish. An apology isn't an admission of legal liability, so there's no reason to hold one back.

For step 5, think about the system as well as yourself: were two patients' names similar, were you interrupted, did you skip a check of the patient's name? Serious errors rarely have a single cause. More often, several small things go wrong together, such as a busy clinic, a skipped check and two similar names. So avoid being excessively self-critical, and also avoid dismissing the error as something that just happens.

Section 3.4.4

A worked example

"You're a dental student on clinic. A patient has just left after having a tooth taken out, and you realise you gave him another patient's aftercare sheet, with her name and the instructions for a different treatment on it. What would you do?"

1. Patient safety first

"My first concern is the patient who has gone home with the wrong instructions, because he doesn't have the advice he needs on looking after his mouth, or on what to do if it starts bleeding. I'd tell my supervisor straight away, and we'd try to catch him before he left the building, or phone him, so that he gets the right advice today."

2. Take responsibility

"I'd tell my supervisor exactly what happened, including that it was my mistake. I wouldn't wait to see whether he noticed."

3. Tell the patient

"With my supervisor, I'd apologise to him, explain in plain language that he was given the wrong sheet, give him the right one and check he understood it. The sheet also had another patient's name and treatment on it, so her confidentiality has been broken. I'd ask him to return it or destroy it, and I'd expect her to be told what happened and to receive an apology too."

4. Report it

"I'd record what happened and complete an incident report, so the clinic can look at how the sheets are handed out."

5. Reflect and learn

"Afterwards, I'd think about what led to it. Were two sheets left next to each other? Was I rushing at the end of a session? In future, I'd check the name on anything before I hand it over, and I'd talk it through with my tutor."

The mistake affects two patients, and the second is easy to forget. The man needs the right advice today, and the woman's information has been given to a stranger, even though she never saw the sheet. Three things would seriously weaken an otherwise good answer: waiting to see if anything happens, not telling the patients, and blaming the dental nurse or a busy clinic before taking responsibility for your own part.

Section 3.4.5

When nobody would ever know

Interviewers often remove the obvious reason to admit the mistake, to see whether you'd still admit it. "The patient wasn't harmed and doesn't know." "You noticed the error in the notes before anyone acted on it, and nobody saw you write it." Either way, you tell a senior and report it. Near misses, which are errors caught before they reach the patient, must still be reported, because they show where the next error could happen. Whether to tell the patient depends on whether they could be harmed. A patient may not need to be told about an error that was caught before it reached them and can't cause them harm, such as treatment recorded against the wrong tooth and corrected before anything was done. But a patient who has gone home with the wrong advice must be told even if he seems fine, because harm may still follow.

If the mistake is in the records, correct it openly. Add a dated, signed correction, and never delete or alter the original entry, because records have to show what was known and when.

These stations often end with a personal question: "Tell me about a time you made a mistake." Choose a genuine, minor mistake rather than a strength presented as a weakness, take responsibility for it, and spend most of your answer on what you changed afterwards. Some stations also ask how you'd feel. Be honest that it would affect you, and say where you'd get support, such as your supervisor, rather than dismissing it or dwelling on it.

Section 3.4.6

What's next

The last lesson in this module covers knowledge questions: the key law and guidance, such as consent, capacity and confidentiality, that the other types of question depend on.

Put Your Knowledge to the Test

Tackle ethics questions from real dental school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.

Try a Question