Ethics·Lesson 3.2·6 min read
Dilemmas
What are dilemma questions?
In a dilemma question, you're given a scenario where two ethical principles conflict, and there may be no clear right or wrong answer. The aim is to assess your ability to recognise the ethical issues involved, explore different perspectives, and weigh up competing principles before reaching a reasoned conclusion. What matters most isn't necessarily the position you take, but how well you justify it. You should demonstrate empathy, balanced judgement, and an understanding of your professional responsibilities. However, your reasoning must always remain within legal and professional boundaries.
Examples of dilemma questions
Most are phrased as "Should…?" or "Is it ever acceptable…?":
- "Is it ever acceptable to break confidentiality?"
- "Should it be compulsory for doctors to be vaccinated against COVID-19?"
- "A man had a liver transplant for alcohol-related liver disease, and has started drinking again. Should he be offered a second liver?"
The five-step balanced argument
For dilemma questions, we recommend a five-step balanced argument. Take the steps in order:
- 1.Identify the issue. Say in one sentence what the question is really about: "This is about whether it's fair to ration care by behaviour." Then name any assumptions or missing information (if applicable): "I'm assuming the patient has capacity." Identifying missing information shows that you are thinking carefully about the scenario.
- 2.Weigh both sides. Give two or three points each way, thinking about everyone affected: the patient, their family, staff, other patients and the wider NHS.
- 3.Apply the four pillars. Say briefly how each one applies to this scenario, then name where they conflict. Apply them to the facts of the station rather than listing them.
- 4.Use guidance or law. One accurate reference is enough. If you don't know the exact guidance, say what you'd expect it to say rather than inventing it.
- 5.Balanced conclusion with reflection. "On balance I think..., because..., although I'd think differently if..."
Avoid ending on "it depends". If your answer depends on something, say what it depends on and which way you lean.
A note about frameworks
Frameworks give you somewhere to start. Without one, it's easy to freeze, or to say whatever comes to mind in no particular order. But a framework isn't a script. It's a tool to help you think and build a well-structured answer.
Use it as a mental map to organise your thoughts, and still talk naturally. Don't say "I'll be using the five-step balanced argument. Step one is…", as that sounds rehearsed and mechanical. Let the structure show in the order of what you say.
If there's no reading time, it's fine to ask for a moment before you start. "Can I take a few seconds to think?" is a normal thing to say, and a short pause followed by a clear answer is much better than starting straight away and rambling.
Common dilemmas and where the tension lies
Finding the conflict in step 3 is often the hardest part to do on the spot. Most dilemmas are versions of a few recurring ones, so it helps to know the clash in each, and the point that usually settles it, before you walk in.
| Dilemma | The clash | What usually settles it |
|---|---|---|
| Lifestyle and treatment (smoking, obesity, alcohol, transplants...) | Beneficence (treating this patient) vs justice (fair use of limited resources) | Separating a clinical reason (it makes treatment less safe or effective) from a moral one (they deserve it less) |
| An expensive drug for a rare disease | Beneficence (treating this patient) vs justice (what else the money could pay for) | Opportunity cost. NICE judges whether a treatment is cost-effective using QALYs, a measure of how much extra healthy life it gives |
| One organ, several patients | Beneficence (doing the most good with the organ) vs justice (treating each patient fairly) | Urgency and likely benefit count; job, social worth and blame don't. In reality, organs are allocated by a national scheme, not one doctor |
| A patient refuses life-saving treatment (e.g. a blood transfusion) | Autonomy vs beneficence | Capacity. An adult with capacity can refuse, even if the decision seems unwise |
| Breaking confidentiality | Autonomy (the patient's control over their own information) vs non-maleficence (preventing harm to others) | Whether there's a risk of serious harm to others, and whether the patient can be persuaded to disclose themselves |
| Assisted dying | Autonomy vs non-maleficence | The law. Assisted dying is illegal in the UK, so show that you understand both sides, then make clear that doctors have to follow the law (see the Knowledge lesson) |
A worked example
Here is the framework applied to a common question.
"Should smokers get lower priority for NHS treatment?"
A strong answer:
"This is really about whether it's fair to ration NHS care by people's behaviour, and whether that's a doctor's judgement to make.
There are arguments for it. Resources are limited, and some treatments work less well in people who keep smoking: wounds heal more slowly, for example. Some would also say it encourages personal responsibility.
But the arguments against are strong. Smoking is an addiction, not a simple choice, and it's closely linked to deprivation, so this would hit the poorest hardest. It's hard to know where you'd stop: sports injuries, or skin cancer after sunbathing? And patients might stop being honest with their doctors.
Looking at the four pillars, beneficence points towards treating, because smokers still stand to benefit. Non-maleficence matters where smoking makes an operation riskier. Autonomy is less clear-cut than it looks, because addiction limits how free the choice is. The real tension is between beneficence, which means treating this patient, and justice, which means using limited resources fairly and treating everyone equally. And the GMC is clear that doctors must not refuse or delay treatment because they believe a patient's actions contributed to their condition.
So on balance, I don't think smokers should get lower priority as a judgement on their choices. Priority should follow clinical need and how likely treatment is to help. Where smoking genuinely makes an operation less safe, it's reasonable to delay it while helping the patient stop, because that's about their outcome, not a punishment. I'd only think differently if a treatment simply wouldn't work unless the behaviour changed."
What makes this answer strong is the conclusion. It separates "smoking makes this operation riskier" from "they deserve it less", which is the distinction behind almost every question about lifestyle and treatment. It also takes a side and says what would change it. The pillars are covered in four sentences, each tied to the facts of the case, rather than recited as a list. Notice what it doesn't do: it never suggests smokers deserve less. Making moral judgements about a patient's choices will lose marks, regardless of your conclusion.
Two weak answers come up again and again.
One-sided: "No. Everyone deserves treatment, and the NHS should treat everyone equally." This is a reasonable view, but it doesn't consider the arguments on the other side.
Fence-sitting: "There are good arguments on both sides. It's a really difficult question and it depends on the situation." This feels safe, but it only shows that you can list arguments, not that you can evaluate them and reach a conclusion.
Note that for most dilemmas there's no one correct answer. You could justify the opposite conclusion and score just as well, as long as your reasoning is strong and your recommendation stays within the law and GMC guidance.
When the interviewer pushes back
Once you've given your view, expect the interviewer to test it. Follow-up questions are usually planned in advance, so being challenged doesn't mean you're wrong.
- If they challenge you without adding anything new, acknowledge the point and explain why you still hold your view.
- If they add new information, say how it changes your answer. Changing your mind for a stated reason is a strength. Switching sides without a reason, or ignoring the new facts, is not.
- If they ask you to choose, give a clear decision. "If you had to decide today, what would you do?" is asking for a decision, and avoiding it a second time will lose marks.
Raise the key points yourself, before you're asked. At some schools, needing to be prompted can lower your score, so don't wait to be asked about the other side or the guidance. And don't rush to reach every follow-up: a full first answer scores better than a thin one followed by more questions.
What's next
The next lesson covers professionalism questions, where there usually is a right answer, and the skill is responding in proportion to the risk.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle ethics questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.