Menu

NHS & Topical Issues·Lesson 10.3·8 min read

"Should the NHS…?" Questions

Most decisions about healthcare help some people and cost others. A charge for missed appointments might cut the number of wasted appointments, but it would fall hardest on patients who are already struggling. Doctors and governments have to make these decisions all the time, and interviewers want to see how you would make them, so they ask questions that begin with "Should…". This lesson covers how to weigh the two sides, how to reach a view, and how to defend your view when the interviewer challenges it.

Section 10.3.1

Examples of "should" questions

These questions ask whether a policy is a good idea, and they can be about the NHS, about public health or about doctors themselves. For example:

  • "Should the NHS charge patients who miss their appointments?"
  • "Should the NHS be privatised?"
  • "Should doctors be able to strike?"
Section 10.3.2

What interviewers look for

For most of these questions there is no right answer, and interviewers will accept either conclusion if it's well argued. They look for three things:

  1. 1.Arguments on both sides. Give the best arguments against your own view as well as the arguments for it.
  2. 2.A decision. After weighing both sides, you need to say which one you agree with. Some applicants avoid taking a side because they want to seem balanced, but the question asks for your view, so an answer without one is incomplete.
  3. 3.A view you can defend. Interviewers often disagree with your conclusion on purpose, to see how you respond.
Section 10.3.3

How to answer

We recommend four steps for a "should" question:

  1. 1.Say what happens now. Start by explaining what the policy is and what the current position is, since this can change the whole argument. With privatisation, for example, private companies already provide some NHS care that is free to patients, and most GP practices are independent businesses. Patients paying for their own care would be a much bigger change, so say which of the two you're discussing.
  2. 2.Give the main arguments on each side. Two or three for each side is enough. For each one, say who would benefit and who would lose out, since most of these policies help one group and cost another.
  3. 3.Weigh them. Say which arguments you find most important, and why. You can consider how many people are affected, how seriously, and whether the people who lose out are those least able to afford it.
  4. 4.Give your view. Say clearly what you would do. You can attach a condition, such as "I'd support it as long as…", but avoid finishing with "there are good arguments on both sides".
Section 10.3.4

A worked example

"Should the UK have a sugar tax?"

Here is a strong answer, following the four steps, with the last two given together:

  1. 1.What happens now. "A sugar tax puts a charge on high-sugar products, usually drinks, to cut how much sugar people consume and to push manufacturers to take sugar out. The UK has had one since 2018, the Soft Drinks Industry Levy, charged on manufacturers per litre above a sugar threshold."
  2. 2.The arguments. "The strongest argument for it is that it worked in a way nobody quite expected. Many manufacturers cut the sugar in their drinks before the tax started, so the sugar in soft drinks fell a lot without people having to change what they bought. Children and teenagers drink the most sugary drinks, so they have the most to gain, and obesity among 10 and 11 year old girls fell after the tax came in. The money raised was originally promised to school sport and breakfast clubs. Against it, the cost falls hardest on lower-income households, who spend a bigger share of their income on food and drink, so on its own it's regressive. People can also switch to untaxed sugary snacks, and the tax only covers drinks, when a lot of sugar comes from food."
  3. 3.Weighing them, and my view. "On balance I think it's justified, mainly because of the reformulation effect. But it should be paired with measures that make healthy options cheaper, and not only make unhealthy ones dearer, so that the people it bears on hardest also get the benefit."

The candidate knows that the UK has had a sugar tax since 2018, so they can describe what it has done instead of guessing what it might do. For each argument they say who is affected, such as teenagers and lower-income households. They then give a clear view and the main reason for it, and the condition at the end answers the best argument against their view.

Section 10.3.5

When the interviewer challenges you

After an answer like this, the interviewer will often challenge your view, for example "But isn't it unfair that poorer families end up paying more?" Interviewers do this whichever side you take, so it isn't a sign that your answer was wrong. You can respond in one of three ways:

  • Defend your view. Explain why the point doesn't change your conclusion. For example, "It is unfair if they pay more, but because many drinks were reformulated, many families are buying the same drinks with less sugar in them and paying no tax on them."
  • Adjust your view. Accept the point and add a condition to your answer, such as spending the money raised in the areas that pay the most.
  • Change your mind. If the interviewer raises something you hadn't considered and it convinces you, say so. It's fine to change your view when you're given a good reason.

Avoid repeating your first answer in different words, and avoid dropping your view as soon as it's questioned.

Section 10.3.6

Questions about patients' choices

Some of these questions are about patients whose illness is linked to how they live, such as "Should the NHS charge patients for treating illnesses related to smoking, alcohol or obesity?" Take care with these questions, because interviewers are concerned by applicants who suggest that some patients deserve treatment less than others.

We recommend starting from the fact that the NHS treats patients according to their clinical need. You can add that smoking, obesity and the harm done by alcohol are all more common in poorer areas, and smoking and drinking can be addictions, so a charge would mostly fall on people who are already disadvantaged. It would also be hard to decide where to stop, because if the NHS charged smokers, the same argument would apply to people who are injured playing rugby. If you want to give the other side, use a clinical argument. Some operations are riskier or less likely to work while a patient is still smoking, so a doctor might delay surgery and offer help with stopping first.

Section 10.3.7

What's next

The next lesson covers how to talk about a news story, and how to discuss an article that a medical school sends you before your interview.

Put Your Knowledge to the Test

Tackle topical questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.

Try a Question