NHS & Topical Issues·Lesson 10.2·8 min read
The Pressures on the NHS
The NHS is under a lot of pressure. Waiting lists are long, A&E departments are overcrowded and many hospitals are short of staff. As a medical student and a doctor you'll be working under these pressures, so interviewers often ask what you think the biggest problems are and how they could be solved. To answer well, you need to understand how the problems are connected and not only list them, because many of them have the same cause. This lesson covers how the main pressures on the NHS fit together, and how to answer questions about its biggest challenges.
Examples of these questions
Some of these questions ask you to choose the biggest problem, and others ask you to explain a problem or to decide how to fix one. For example:
- "What do you think is the biggest challenge facing the NHS?"
- "Why are waiting times in A&E so long?"
- "Imagine you're the new Health Secretary, and you've been given an extra one billion pounds to spend on the NHS. Where would you spend it?"
How a patient moves through the NHS
To see how the pressures are connected, it helps to follow a patient through the NHS. A patient has to get in, be treated and then leave, and each of these three stages is under pressure.
Getting in. Most patients first see a GP, and those with an emergency call 999 or go to A&E. Demand at this stage keeps rising, mainly because the population is getting older and more people have several long-term conditions at once. When patients can't get a GP appointment, some of them go to A&E instead.
In hospital. A hospital can only treat as many patients as it has beds, and a bed can only be used if there are staff to look after the patient in it. Staff shortages therefore limit how many patients a hospital can treat, even where it has the space. About 100,000 NHS posts in England are vacant.
Getting out. Many patients, especially older ones, can't go home until care has been arranged for them, such as carers who visit at home or a place in a care home. This is social care, which in England is arranged by local councils and is short of money and staff. When it isn't available, the patient stays in hospital even though they no longer need to be there. On a typical day, more than 13,000 patients in England are well enough to leave hospital but can't, and waiting for social care is one of the main reasons.
How the pressures connect
A delay at one stage causes problems at the stages before it. When patients can't be discharged, the wards have no free beds. Patients in A&E who need to be admitted then have to wait in the department, sometimes on trolleys in corridors, until a bed is free. Once A&E is full, ambulances can't hand over their patients, so they queue outside and can't respond to the next 999 call. Working in these conditions also makes staff more likely to leave, which means that even fewer beds can be staffed.
The same shortage of beds affects planned care. When a hospital is full of emergency patients, it has to cancel planned operations, and this is one of the reasons that the waiting list in England stands at about 7.4 million treatments, for about 6.2 million patients.
This means that the cause of a problem is often in a different part of the NHS from where the problem appears. Long waits in A&E look as if they're caused by too many people arriving, but much of the delay comes from patients who can't leave the wards.
How to answer a "biggest challenge" question
There is no correct challenge to choose, and interviewers mark how well you justify the one you pick. We recommend the SPIRER framework, shown here with an answer about social care:
- 1.Situation. Outline the problem in a sentence. Choose one challenge, or two if the question asks for two, because naming five leaves no time to explain any of them. For example, "I think the biggest challenge is the shortage of social care, which means that many patients can't leave hospital when they're well enough to."
- 2.Problem. Say why it's important and who it affects, and support it with a figure you know or something you saw on work experience. For example, "On my placement, a nurse told me that several patients on her ward had been ready to go home for over a week."
- 3.Implications. Give the short-term and long-term consequences. This is your reason for choosing the challenge, and it answers the follow-up question "Why that one?" before it's asked. For example, "When patients can't be discharged, there are no free beds, and that leads to long waits in A&E and cancelled operations. In the longer term, working in these conditions makes staff more likely to leave."
- 4.Response. Say what is being done or what could be done, and name its drawback. "More funding" isn't a solution on its own, so say what the money would be spent on. For example, "Better pay for care workers would help to fill vacancies, but it would have to be funded through councils or taxation, and it wouldn't free up beds quickly."
- 5.Ethics. Link the issue to the four pillars of medical ethics, or to GMC guidance. For example, "This is partly a question of justice, because a bed used by someone who no longer needs it isn't available to someone who does."
- 6.Reflection. Finish with what the issue means for you as a future doctor. For example, "As a doctor, I'd need to start planning each patient's discharge early, and work closely with the social workers and the rest of the team."
The same steps work for questions that ask you to explain a problem, such as "Why are waiting times in A&E so long?" For these, trace the problem back through the three stages to where it starts.
"If you were Health Secretary…"
Some questions put you in charge and give you a budget. These questions test whether you can prioritise, so an answer that gives a little money to everything scores poorly. A strong answer covers five things:
- 1.The scale of the money. One billion pounds sounds large, but it's a small share of the health budget, so it has to be concentrated on one area.
- 2.How you'll choose. Say what you're judging the options by, such as how many people would benefit and whether there's evidence that the spending works.
- 3.Your decision. Mention the main options briefly, and then commit to one.
- 4.What you won't fund. Say who loses out because of your choice. Interviewers often raise this themselves if you don't.
- 5.How you'd know it had worked. Name one or two things you would measure.
A worked example
"Imagine you're the new Health Secretary, and you've been given an extra one billion pounds to spend on the NHS. Where would you spend it, and why?"
Here is a strong answer, following the five steps:
- 1.Scale. "The health budget for England is over 200 billion pounds a year, so one billion is roughly half of one per cent, or about two days of spending. Spread evenly it would disappear, so it has to be concentrated where it can change something."
- 2.How I'd choose. "I'd judge the options by four things: how many people are affected and how badly, whether there's good evidence that the spending works, whether it narrows health inequalities, and whether it reduces future demand or only relieves today's pressure."
- 3.My decision. "The main options are waiting lists, social care, the workforce and prevention. Extra capacity for waiting lists gives quick, visible results, but it treats the symptom of rising demand. Social care would free up hospital beds, though it sits outside the NHS, and one billion would make little difference to care workers' pay across the country. So I would invest in prevention and early diagnosis through GPs and community services, targeted at the most deprived areas. For example, stop-smoking services are among the most cost-effective interventions in healthcare, and outreach could raise the uptake of cervical screening and childhood vaccines, which has fallen over the last ten years."
- 4.What I wouldn't fund. "Every pound spent here is a pound not spent on someone waiting in pain for a hip replacement today, and the benefits of prevention take years to show. That's a real cost. But waiting lists will keep refilling unless demand is reduced, and hospitals already receive the largest share of spending."
- 5.How I'd know it worked. "I'd set measures before spending the money, such as screening and vaccination uptake, smoking rates and the gap between the most and least deprived areas, so that what works can be expanded and what doesn't can be stopped."
This answer starts by showing that the candidate understands how small one billion pounds is, which explains why they go on to choose a single area. They state how they will judge the options before they decide, so the decision follows from reasons the interviewer has already heard. They mention the alternatives in a sentence each, and then commit to one. They also admit that their choice leaves patients on waiting lists without help, and explain why they would still make it. A candidate could choose social care or waiting lists and score just as well, as long as the reasoning is as clear.
What's next
The next lesson covers questions that ask whether the NHS should do something, such as charging for missed appointments.
Put Your Knowledge to the Test
Tackle topical questions from real medical school interviews with our realistic AI interviewer, then receive personalised feedback and model answers.